Family Favorites Orange Sherbet

The  newest Better Homes & Garden Red Plaid 15th edition.has a great recipe for Orange Sherbet. We all thought it was a five star recipe. Lyle who doesn’t like sherbet said this was great. Sherbet has milk in it, Sorbet does not. That is the difference between the two. Sherbet is icier than ice cream but still smooth not grainy. This recipe has unflavored gelatin in it, be sure to combine it with the sugar when you start.
  I did use all fresh squeezed Valencia oranges. These are a juice orange and are mainly sold to processors for orange juice. Our Fareway store has had them this year and they really do give you more juice per orange. It took 9 oranges for 6 cups of sherbet. This will vary with the type and size of oranges you buy. If you think you do not like sherbet  I hope some of you will try this. It definitely does not taste like the commercial versions.  It's perfect for your Labor Day celebration.
Orange Sherbet
Makes 6 cups
1 ½ cups sugar
1 envelope unflavored gelatin
1 teaspoon finely shredded orange peel
3 ¾ cups orange juice
1 cup milk
  In a medium saucepan combine sugar and gelatin. Stir in 2 cups orange juice. Cook and stir until sugar and gelatin dissolve, Remove from heat. Stir in remaining orange juice, the orange peel, milk and a few drops orange food coloring if desired. (Mixture might appear curdled.) 
  Transfer mixture to a 4 quart ice cream freezer, freeze according to model directions. Ripen for 4 hours for best flavor. (I chilled the mixture in the freezer for 20 minutes before putting in machine because my kitchen was warm)
NOTE: If you don’t have a ice cream freezer transfer mixture to a 13x9x2 inch pan. Cover; freeze 2 to 3 hours or until almost firm. Break mixture into small chunks; transfer to a large mixing bowl. Beat with an electric mixer until smooth but not melted. Return to pan. Cover and freeze until firm.

Cost 2011: 9 oranges $4.50  1 cup whole milk $1.29  1 ½ cups sugar 40¢  gelatin 40¢
Total cost $6.59  1 cup $1.10


  1. I miss buying Valencia oranges since moving to Montana; the stores back in Georgia carry them. I love Orange Sherbert and can't wait to try this, after my next grocery trip.

  2. Hi Lori, Sorry to hear you can't get the Valencia's anymore. Our local store is carrying them more often now.
    The sherbet is very good and so much better than store bought. Hope you all like it.


Hi...we'd love to hear from you.